[OSGeo-Discuss] [Board] Request for a moratorium on AI/LLM use within OSGeo

Tobias Wendorff tobias.wendorff at tu-dortmund.de
Mon Nov 9 03:47:35 PST 2026


Hi Javier,

thanks for your reponse.

I wasn't replying to the main thread - I was just replying to Evan's
comment.

But of course, you're there are two aspects: the use of LLMs to generate
code within OSGeo projects and the use of existing open-source code to
train LLMs.

However, I don't think these questions are entirely unrelated. Even
explicitly described these tools as a "privatization of human knowledge
into monopolies" and raised concerns about the work of open-source
contributors being taken without proper recognition or compensation.
That's why I brought up the broader question of how we deal with the
reuse of open-source code and knowledge.

I also take your point about a default policy being different from
an imposed rule. My concern is more about how much freedom individual
projects would have to deviate from that default in practice.

I think we should be able to discuss both the legitimate concerns
about the AI industry and the potential benefits of these technologies
for open-source development.

I'm sorry this wasn't the right place to share my opinion.
I'll keep quiet from now on and let you people discuss the future.

Best,
Tobias

Am 2026-11-09 12:34, schrieb Javier Jimenez Shaw:
> Hi Tobias
> 
> You mention a topic (how are LLMs using the OSS code), that is valid,
> but it is not the topic discussed initially in this thread.
> Even is talking about the usage of LLMs in the generation of our
> software in OSGeo, not if we allow LLMs to be trained with our code.
> 
> And Even is not saying to impose, but to define a default:
> "At least as a by-default policy. Each group could potentially reframe
> it, but by default, I believe groups should be protected"
> 
> Cheers
> Javier


More information about the Discuss mailing list