[fdo-trac] #145: Questionable Provenance for some GDAL Provider Test Data

[FDO]

#145: Questionable Provenance for some GDAL Provider Test Data
---------------------------+------------------------------------------------
 Reporter:  warmerdam      |         Owner:  gregb
     Type:  defect         |        Status:  new  
 Priority:  major          |     Milestone:  3.3.0
Component:  GDAL Provider  |       Version:  3.2.0
 Severity:  3              |    Resolution:       
 Keywords:  license        |   External_id:       
---------------------------+------------------------------------------------
Old description:

> Per the FDO Provenance Review some raster data in GDAL/TestData has
> unknown origins.
>
> http://wiki.osgeo.org/index.php/FDO_Provenance_Review#Providers.2FGDAL.2FTestData.2Farea1
>
> This ticket is an attempt to track an action item to review questionable
> items, and potentially re-engineer the unit tests to use other, known
> safe, data.
>
> Current "at issue" data:
>  * band/Airport.sid
>  * Ecw/golf_course.ecw
>  * Greyscale/ikonos.ecw
>  * ESRI/ASCII/BenNevis.asc
>  * ESRI/Binary/California/*
>  * GeoTIFF/AspectTest3/*
>  * Jp2/037121f8UTM-LL.j2k
>  * Jp2/Greyscale/tokyo_gray.*
>  * MrSID/Airport.sid
>  * MrSID/Grayscale/36114B51.sid
>  * PNG/*
>
> Action items:
>  * GregB: review other oustanding data.
>  * FrankW: replace data no one can speak for, with comparible safe
> testdata and update unit tests accordingly.

New description:

 Per the FDO Provenance Review some raster data in GDAL/TestData has
 unknown origins.

 http://wiki.osgeo.org/index.php/FDO_Provenance_Review#Providers.2FGDAL.2FTestData.2Farea1

 This ticket is an attempt to track an action item to review questionable
 items, and potentially re-engineer the unit tests to use other, known
 safe, data.

 Current "at issue" data:
  * ESRI/ASCII/BenNevis.asc
  * ESRI/Binary/California/*
  * GeoTIFF/AspectTest3/*
  * Jp2/037121f8UTM-LL.j2k
  * Jp2/Greyscale/tokyo_gray.*
  * MrSID/Airport.sid
  * MrSID/Grayscale/36114B51.sid
  * PNG/*

 Action items:
  * GregB: review other oustanding data.
  * FrankW: replace data no one can speak for, with comparible safe
 testdata and update unit tests accordingly.

Comment (by gregboone):

 The following files have been addressed in the TestData directory:

  * band/Airport.sid
  * Ecw/golf_course.ecw
  * Greyscale/ikonos.ecw
  * Jp2/037121f8UTM-LL.j2k
  * Jp2/Greyscale/tokyo_gray.*
  * MrSID/Airport.sid
  * MrSID/Grayscale/36114B51.sid
  * PNG/*

 The following files are not proprietary:

  * GeoTIFF/AspectTest3/*

-- 
Ticket URL: <http://trac.osgeo.org/fdo/ticket/145#comment:2>
FDO <http://fdo.osgeo.org/>
Feature Data Objects