[Qgis-developer] Support for field aliases in expressions

[kimaidou]

Hi Matthias,

Ok for keeping support for both field name and field alias. This sounds
right to me.

For the attribute table, I would prefer a context menu button ("hamburger"
style) for the horizontal header instead of tooltip, as the latter are
often not well known by users (or they discover tooltips randomly)

Thanks for your work !

Michael

2014-09-11 9:28 GMT+02:00 Matthias Kuhn <matthias.kuhn at gmx.ch>:

> Hi Michael and Martin,
>
> On Wed 10 Sep 2014 07:38:15 PM CEST, kimaidou wrote:
>
>> Hi all,
>>
>> I am not sure using alias would be easier for the users. Some thoughts :
>>
>> * sometimes aliases are quite complicated, like "Contexte de
>> l'édition" for a field named "context". We would need to escape
>> properly aliases in expressions. And in this example, the real field
>> name is much easier and shorter thant the alias
>>
>> * aliases can vary between projects or even between duplicate layers
>> in the same project, whereas field names are stable. If I cannot reuse
>> some expression for the same source table because I use different
>> aliases, I would spend more time to rewrite the expressions ( except
>> if we allow to use both in expression, but the user must then do the
>> right choice)
>>
>
>
> Disabling support for field names is not an option. Support would be for
> both in parallel.
> Field names can can be written in double quotes already, so the only thing
> that will need to be escaped are double quotes (which are probably rarely
> used in alias names).
>
> The one thing that needs a decision is what the expression builder inserts
> into the expression when the user chooses a field there. I would not mind
> making the usage of aliases there optional.
>
>  * I think the problem is more that as soon as you use alias for some
>> field, it is then very "difficult" to find back what is the real name
>> of the column in the source "table" : aliases are displayed instead of
>> the column in every part of the Gui, which is fine but sometimes not
>> wanted. For example, I would love to have a button in the attribute
>> table which let me toggle between the aliases and the real field names
>> as the table header.
>>
>
> They would be listed both in the expression builder: "Alias (field_name)",
> so you would have one more place where you have the combination.
> In the attribute table, I would prefer to have it either in a context menu
> of the horizontal header. Another approach would be a tooltip (where I
> wanted to add the field comment anyway).
>
>
>> 2014-09-10 19:00 GMT+02:00 Martin Dobias <wonder.sk at gmail.com
>> <mailto:wonder.sk at gmail.com>>:
>>
>>>
>>>      I am just wondering... how the aliases would be made accessible to
>>     QgsExpression? Would be a map of aliases from vector layer set to each
>>     QgsExpression instace? Or extend QgsFields to support also aliases? Or
>>     something completely different? :-)
>>
>
> I did not put any thoughts into the implementation yet. But I was thinking
> about the second idea (saving aliases in QgsField) before. I think it would
> be better suited there than keeping it separately. Are you sceptical
> concerning this approach?
>
> Best
> Matthias
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.osgeo.org/pipermail/qgis-developer/attachments/20140912/bffddb51/attachment-0001.html>