[GRASS-dev] Keywords for r.null and in general

[Markus Neteler]

Hi,

On Tue, Nov 26, 2019 at 1:18 PM Veronica Andreo <veroandreo at gmail.com> wrote:
>
> Hi Vaclav
>
> El mar., 26 nov. 2019 a las 0:18, Vaclav Petras (<wenzeslaus at gmail.com>) escribió:
>>
>> Hi all,
>>
>> I'm just seeking quick feedback on keywords for r.null module and adding some general questions for discussion if needed. I just added r.null.all to addons (do r.null for multiple maps) with keywords:
>>
>> raster
>> map management
>> null data
>> no-data
>>
>> while MarkusN pointed out in the PR that r.null has only
>>
>> raster
>> null data
>>
>> Does the above make sense? The PR for it is easy, but the question here are more general, so I wonder how people are using the keywords. (As a reminder, first keywords is module family (raster, vector, ...), second is topic, third and others are just normal keywords.)
>>
>> 1) Should be we have synonyms in keywords, i.e., both null data and no-data 2) Should we repeat the words from the name of module, i.e., null or null data? 3) Should different spellings be included, e.g., no-data and NoData?
>>
>> I'm saying yes first two questions, so that's why I included raster, map management, null data, no-data.
>
>
> I also tend to say yes to 1) and 2)

yes to 1) and 2)

> Regarding 3), I'm not sure about different spellings, but I'm in for synomyns

IMHO different spellings are confusing, so 3) no also from my point of view

4) synomyns

yes

Best
Markus