[GRASS-dev] Keywords for r.null and in general

Veronica Andreo veroandreo at gmail.com
Tue Nov 26 04:18:27 PST 2019

Hi Vaclav

El mar., 26 nov. 2019 a las 0:18, Vaclav Petras (<wenzeslaus at gmail.com>)

> Hi all,
> I'm just seeking quick feedback on keywords for r.null module and adding
> some general questions for discussion if needed. I just added r.null.all to
> addons (do r.null for multiple maps) with keywords:
> raster
> map management
> null data
> no-data
> while MarkusN pointed out in the PR that r.null has only
> raster
> null data
> Does the above make sense? The PR for it is easy, but the question here
> are more general, so I wonder how people are using the keywords. (As a
> reminder, first keywords is module family (raster, vector, ...), second is
> topic, third and others are just normal keywords.)
> 1) Should be we have synonyms in keywords, i.e., both null data and
> no-data 2) Should we repeat the words from the name of module, i.e., null
> or null data? 3) Should different spellings be included, e.g., no-data and
> NoData?
> I'm saying yes first two questions, so that's why I included raster, map
> management, null data, no-data.

I also tend to say yes to 1) and 2)
Regarding 3), I'm not sure about different spellings, but I'm in for

my 0.2 cents

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.osgeo.org/pipermail/grass-dev/attachments/20191126/de95b701/attachment.html>

More information about the grass-dev mailing list