[Marketing] Proposal to subscribe to an email platform for all of OSGeo committees

Mon Sep 21 18:43:35 PDT 2020

I think Marketing is the right place, but only if enough of the 
Conference members who are making this request are present (I'm not on 
that list so had to drop it from my response). I'm adding in my opinion 
as a SAC member but this had not been discussed thoroughly with the 
whole committee. Marketing once it has defined the specific needs, and 
growth expectations can request further exploration from SAC.

As mentioned in another thread in Marketing, copied here to bring it in 
to the conversation...

I'd like to see a more complete comparison of options, and little more 
info on expected usage based on previous numbers, and future anticipated 
expansion.
https://alternativeto.net/software/mailchimp/

Noting things like Campyn has a 15% non-profit discount and a 
pay-as-you-go option.

LAMP stack is pretty straightforward, we do not at this time have an AWS 
account. Not saying it's out of the question but it's more complexity 
than one might think to maintain access/persmissions, billing tags, 
etc... Might even opt to use a pre-built AWS lightsail LAMP to even skip 
on most of the setup work.

Per usual if someone not currently on SAC is interested in becoming the 
admin that would add weight to any self hosted options.

Others have pointed out the biggest concern is getting blacklisted. We 
want either a 3rd party service or something like Sendy where 
unsubscribe is simple/easy and all the anti-spam magic is added to the 
sending.

Thanks,
Alex
System Admin Committee

On 9/16/20 2:30 AM, Steven Feldman wrote:
> Hi
> 
> I posted to Marketing, Conference and Board because I wasn’t sure which committee should be involved? If one of the Committee chairs wants to “own" this thread we can switch to one list only.
> 
> Re Adam’s comments:
> Our current mailing lists are primarily for a bi-directional conversation amongst our community, they are not for marketing - they do not deliver graphics and formatting easily, the signup process is clunky, confusing and does not integrate easily.
> An e-mail service (MailChimp or Sendy) is for outbound marketing comms only (at large or very large scale) and usually provides some analytics about the success of a mail campaign. This is important for all of our outreach activities
> All of the people on our lists have given their permission to receive further mails from OSGeo/FOSS4G, we gathered nearly 800 permissions out of 1,000 registrations for FOSS4GUK2020. The email service needs to have a simple opt-out option, the possibility to configure personal preferences (eg region of interest), record sources of contacts and comply with GDPR
> The Sendy approach uses the Amazon Simple Email Service to actually send the emails which means that we do not have to run a mail server or have concerns re spam blocking.
> 
> 
> ______
> Steven
> 
> Unusual maps in strange places -  mappery.org <http://mappery.org/>
> 
> Subscribe to my weekly “Maps in the Wild <http://eepurl.com/dKStT-/>” newsletter
> 
>> On 15 Sep 2020, at 16:09, María Arias de Reyna <delawen at gmail.com> wrote:
>>
>> Resending because I lost some lists here.
>>
>> Should we focus on only one list? Marketing maybe?
>>
>> On Tue, Sep 15, 2020 at 5:00 PM María Arias de Reyna <delawen at gmail.com <mailto:delawen at gmail.com>> wrote:
>> Hi!
>>
>> Jumping in!
>>
>> On Tue, Sep 15, 2020 at 3:22 PM Adam Steer <adam.d.steer at gmail.com <mailto:adam.d.steer at gmail.com>> wrote:
>> Is there a reason the existing discussion / announce list infrastructure (includingannounce at lists.osgeo.org <mailto:announce at lists.osgeo.org> and foss4gXXXX at lists.osgeo.org <mailto:foss4gXXXX at lists.osgeo.org>) cannot be used? (are there numbers on how much that costs?)
>>
>> Having a better marketing tracking statistics tool.
>>   
>> If we're talking about building infrastructure, is it a good time to talk about wholesale migration for all of OSGeo lists to more modern systems (eg mailman v3 or discourse, or ...)? - using F4G 2021 as the guinea pig?
>>
>> There are open source mailchimp alternatives. I think I mentioned https://www.phplist.com/ <https://www.phplist.com/> before. As long as we have a mail server available to  send the emails... do we?
>>
>> Current FOSS4G team lacks the workforce to add an open source code alternative to mailchimp to the stack. We are focusing on Pretix and Pretalx at this point, which we hope will be useful as a base event OSGeo stack.
>>
>> But if there's some volunteer that can look into phplist and deploy it, please, be my guest!!! We just don't want to add more tasks on our shoulders at this moment. Although the final decision should go through conference and marketing committees I guess.
>>   
>> Is sharing mailing lists ethical/permitted? My argument here is that when a subscriber signs up they should be allowed to give (or not) permission about how (and by whom) they are contacted in future - in the example a user signs up for FOSS4G2021 communications, we should not (even if it is allowed by law) then share their details in future with some other event *without explicit permission to do so* (do we know for sure that those 10-15k contacts signed up for future communications about conferences?)
>>
>> As far as I know (maybe some LOC slipped), we always have phrased it as "if you want to keep updated on future FOSS4G". And there's no automatic adding to this list when you buy a ticket. Attendees who bought a ticket and people interested in FOSS4G in general are separated lists. And there's always a link to remove yourself from the list. So no problem here with privacy.
>>   
>> ...and what is the purpose for tracking e-mail? do we explain what is tracked and why anywhere? are there examples for people to see? are subscribers plainly made aware that mail to them is tracked?
>>
>> With sendy I see some similarities to mailchimp in that regard, collecting a bunch of stuff for the aim of... is anybody sure?
>>
>> Long story short is: being able to do better marketing to sell more tickets. Collect statistics to understand the kind of things people read more.
>>
>> I agree, this may be interesting to discuss if we *need* it or if we are happy with less statistics and more blind sales. I am no mailchimp/marketing expert so I can only guess here.
>>   
>> I know there's likely some pressure to get messages going out for FOSS4G2021, it'd be great to see it done with awesome data privacy practices and open tooling in mind :)
>>
>> We have the current mailchimp we can spin up whenever we need. But if we are going to move to Sendy and be "guinea pigs", it is better to do it before we start using mailchimp (and adding templates there). Just to not have to migrate/duplicate work.
>>   
>> Regards,
>>
>> Adam
>>
>> Cheers!
>> María
>>
>>
>>
>> On Tue, 15 Sep 2020 at 14:47, Steven Feldman <shfeldman at gmail.com <mailto:shfeldman at gmail.com>> wrote:
>> I have been talking with Malena about a replacement for our MailChimp account for FOSS4G.
>>
>> Our current subscription is paused as it was costing us about $100 per month for 10-15k contacts even though we weren’t sending emails, we can restart the account whenever we need to and start paying the bill again.
>>
>> We have been looking at lower cost ways to send bulk emails to potential delegates for FOSS4G and based on some recommendations and reviews we think Sendy.co <http://sendy.co/> would work for us. If anyone has experience of Sendy please chip in now with your views. There is a one time cost of $59 for a Sendy license which we would need to install on our own server and then a cost of $1 per 10k emails for the Amazon SE <https://aws.amazon.com/ses/pricing/>S mail service plus a bit more for attachments.
>>
>> If we sent up to 100k emails per month (10 campaigns to 10k contacts) with a few graphics our costs would be about $25 per month which is a fraction of the costs with MailChimp.
>>
>> I propose that OSGeo purchases a Sendy license, sets up the self hosted service on our infrastructure and signs up for the Amazon Simple Email Service. We should set this up in a way that allows our Marketing Committee, Regional FOSS4Gs and other groups to have access to the service for managing and sharing (with appropriate privacy controls) mailing lists. This would provide continuity from year to year for our events organisers and could also form the basis for an ongoing dialogue with sponsors
>>
>> Malena and Maria are keen to move our contacts out of MailChimp and to get started mailing people re FOSS4G2021 as soon as possible.
>>
>> Cheers
>> ______
>> Steven
>>
>> Unusual maps in strange places -  mappery.org <http://mappery.org/>
>>
>> Subscribe to my weekly “Maps in the Wild <http://eepurl.com/dKStT-/>” newsletter
>>
>> _______________________________________________
>> Marketing mailing list
>> Marketing at lists.osgeo.org <mailto:Marketing at lists.osgeo.org>
>> https://lists.osgeo.org/mailman/listinfo/marketing <https://lists.osgeo.org/mailman/listinfo/marketing>
> 
> 
> _______________________________________________
> Marketing mailing list
> Marketing at lists.osgeo.org
> https://lists.osgeo.org/mailman/listinfo/marketing
> 