[QGIS-Developer] [otb-developers] qgis-otb-plugin repository moved to OTB's github
alexander.bruy at gmail.com
Fri Jun 9 01:24:35 PDT 2017
let's move this discussion to QGIS dev list.
2017-06-08 20:00 GMT+03:00 Rashad Kanavath <mohammedrashadkm at gmail.com>:
> With new improvements in OTB plugin there is no need to update stuff for
> each release. It work same like GRASS GIS.
> the descriptor files will be generated depending on user's OTB version. IT
> will not be inside algs/otb/descriptor/
Seems there is a misunderstanding here. Description files is a pure-Processing
thing, GRASS does not ship any description files, they were created by
devs and users and updated when necessary.
As I understand, your idea is to move description files to the OTB disctribution
and have some settings in the Processing to point to these description files.
> BTW, When you said adding new functionality and/or bugfixing will be
> problematic, you mean issues in OTB or the plugin?
I was talking about OTB plugin. For example, if you may found and fix a bug
in the plugin or implemented new feature to support new OTB functionality.
If plugin integrated into QGIS you will be tied to QGIS release cycle.
> The way I see otb plugin is a part of processing plugin and it expect data
> (descriptor file) in a specific format from OTB.
> The correct job of otb is give those data so that processing can use it.
> Like GRASS and others, it reads a list of descriptor file and these will be
> provided by OTB not QGIS. When user install a new otb version, descriptor is
> automatically changed with it!
> I hope that takes all the maintenance troubles from QGIS side.
> Finally, if we were able to remove the descriptor folder and gives a plugin
> code (OTBAlgorithm, OTBAlgorithmProvider, OTBUtils)
> which allows users to use any version of OTB package, that will be
> acceptable right?
> And OTB devs will be able to test OTB for compatibility with QGIS.
> Do you know about next QGIS release date and version?
Next QGIS version will be 3.0 and according to the current roadmap 
it is expected in the end of September
More information about the QGIS-Developer