[OSGeo-Edu] licensing (or not) edu material
scropper at botanicusaustralia.com.au
Mon Jul 26 19:32:08 EDT 2010
On Monday 26 July 2010 23:19:08 Charlie Schweik wrote:
> I look forward to hearing Simon's reaction to
> your responses.
Charlie, Puneet and others,
Boy.... talk about throwing kero on the fire!
My first point is, see this is the big elephant in the corner.
My second point is, licensing can be a major obstacle to release of material
on the Internet. Maybe it shouldn't be, but it is!
I'll take various peoples swipe at my hypocrisy, but my expectation is that I
am not all that different than others, it just that I am happy to stand up and
state my concerns, even when it makes me a target.
Yes, I try and use Free & Open Source Software when ever I am able. At present
I use Ubuntu as my operating system. Apart from using some restricted codex
(so I can view files sent by clients) and gvSIG (so I can view ECW files also
used by clients) I am pretty much FOSS compliant.
Yes, I am creating educational material for release to the public.
Yes, it worries me that the information could be misused, misinterpreted, etc.
- I am a scientist. I was trained to collect data, interpret it and write
reports that are attributed to me (for better or worse). Releasing work
that I have no control over its use or abuse is totally against my grain.
- Putting on my other hat, I am a business man (well I hope I am). I have
to ensure, as the Director of Botanicus Australia Pty Ltd, that I do not
expose the company to any undue litigation. Otherwise I could run foul of
Well, I suppose, those are my hang ups. I understand Puneet's concerns and
arguments, but as I have stated and tried to explain it is not that simple.
My point is - licensing is an issue restricting the release of educational
material on the Internet. The meeting should address how this problem can be
Putting it even more simply and personally....
If Public Domain or CC-Zero is the desired license type for educational
material (and half of me says it is), how do you allay my concerns/fears about
attribution, moral rights, misuse, minimising risk, etc; because despite
reading multiple webpages on the subject 'they' are still there.
Botanicus Australia Pty Ltd
PO Box 160 Sunshine 3020
P: 03 9311 5822. M: 041 830 3437
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the Edu_discuss