Revised RFC 1 - Need Comments

[Robert Bray]

One of the reasons I changed this in our PSC document was because it was 
not clear to me in the MapServer process if you needed an RFC to 
nominate or remove members or if just a motion with subsequent 
discussion was required. I just looked again and it's still unclear to 
me. How does that work?

I think our PSC guidelines still has a similar issue and I am just 
trying to sort it all out.

Thanks,
Bob

Daniel Morissette wrote:
> Frank Warmerdam wrote:
>>
>> In my opinion this is adequately covered by the existing voting 
>> mechanism.
>> Someone can be removed by a motion of the PSC.  
>
> OOpps... I checked again and found that clause #12 under the Detailed 
> Process covers removal of members. I had missed it on my first check 
> earlier today. Sorry.
>
> "12. Addition and removal of members from the committee, as well as 
> selection of a Chair should be handled as a proposal to the committee."
>
>
>>
>> Note, I find the concept of purging members that the majority 
>> disagree with
>> somewhat distasteful, but I can imagine circumstances in which it would
>> be appropriate.
>>
>
> Agreed... but when writing contracts or committee processes like this 
> we need to make sure all the ugly cases are covered as well.
>
> Daniel